Opinion

Pollies blinded to the science

TWO SCU scientists made national news headlines this week with their study into the fugitive emissions of gas fields in Queensland. Dr Isaac Santos and Dr Damien Maher have done the first studies into background levels of methane in the atmosphere (typically found at around 1.8 parts per million in areas where there is no gas exploration) and comparing that to the levels of methane around the Tara gas fields, where they found readings as high as 7 parts per million in some locations.

Their findings, whilst preliminary, could have a number of implications for coal seam gas producers.

The main justification for developing the industry is that gas is a 'transition fuel' that has significantly lower emissions than burning coal. But if the levels of 'fugitive emissions' detected by the SCU scientists are found consistently around gas producing areas, the whole raison d'etre disappears in an explosive methane fuelled fireball, because apparently methane that escapes into the atmosphere (as opposed to being burnt) is a much more serious greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide.

The other thing that could be a game-changer for the industry is that if the fugitive emissions can be quantified and attract a carbon tax, then the economic model falls apart.

Predictably, the industry has come out and criticised the research as being 'premature' and lacking scientific rigour.

But then on Tuesday the Federal Minister for Resources Martin Ferguson spoke out at an energy conference in Sydney, describing the scientists involved as "people who are trying to score political points without proper consideration of the best interests of the broader community" (Sydney Morning Herald, November 20).

He also admitted that he had not read the study by Dr Santos and Dr Maher.

This is an incredible attack on the credibility and independence of the scientists and, to me, the clearest indication yet that both federal and state governments are so cosy with sections of the mining industry that they are prepared to do their bidding for them.

Sure there needs to be a lot more research done, but to dismiss it out of hand smacks of outrageous complicity.

Topics:  opinion


Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Have your say on Lismore's signature tree

The Illawarra Flame Tree has been proposed as Lismore's own signature tree.

One person proposed the Illawarra flame tree, we suggest the cedar

Lunch lauds women

Organisers of the Lismore Women's Festival Luncheon Back - left to right: Zoe Dodd, Louise Collins, Sandra Handley Front - left to right: Emily Fajerman, Amelia Bolt, Lois Kelly, Zell Bennett

Festival attracts big names for its luncheon

Hollywood star to shine at high tea

STAR: Virginia Elizabeth 'Geena' Davis is an American actress, film producer, writer, former fashion model, and former archer.

Star of Beetlejuice, Thelma and Louise discussing Women and Media

Local Partners

EAT THE STREET: Save the date for this year's festival

MORE food stalls and cooking demonstrations at the signature Lismore event.

Andy Saunders brings race, family and life into comedy

ON STAGE: Australian comedian Andy Saunders wants to help us all lighten up.

Part of NORPA's Lismore Laughs 2017

BIG RIDE: Matt to bring out smiles for Smiddy

LONG WAY ROUND: Matt Muir raises his bike in triumph on his ride last year.

Fundraiser at Yamba Shores Tavern ahead of 800km charity ride

TLK trio ready to tell stories

Hip Hop outfit Teddy Lewis King are Teddy Rhodes, Mitch King and DJ Mud.

Hip hop troupe prepares to release new single

Tensions high at pointy end of MKR's round two

WHEN an ex-vegan pacifist says "I think people that score strategically need a kick in the shins”, the MKR gloves are off.

Jungle Jay sent packing from I'm a Celebrity

I'm A Celebrity ... Get Me Out Here! contestant Jay Laga'aia with Keira.

BIG friendly giant Jay Laga'aia has been eliminated from I'm A Celeb

Carson Kressley brings 'camp' to I'm a Celebrity jungle

"I am not all Park Avenue and daffodils” ... Carson Kressley.

Meet the "campest” campmate to star on I'm a Celebrity.

Star Wars: The Last Jedi mystery already solved

FILE- This undated file photo provided by Disney shows Daisey Ridley as Rey, left, and John Boyega as Finn, in a scene from the film, \"Star Wars: The Force Awakens.\" Hasbro said it is changing its Star Wars Monopoly set after an 8-year-old girl became upset that Rey, the movie's female heroine, was not included as a figure along with Darth Vader and Kylo Ren. (Disney/Lucasfilm via AP, File) MANDATORY CREDIT

A key mystery surrounding the title of episode eight has been solved

Kids' game "full of f**king paedophiles" according to dad

A mortified dad has expressed serious concerns over an online game

Lisa Marie Presley's ex caught with child pics: court

Lisa Marie Presley, at right, and her husband, Michael Lockwood back in 2010. FILE

Lisa Marie, 49, claimed she was left “sick to her stomach”

Robert Irwin introduces Jimmy Fallon to wild guests

Robert Irwin introduces Tonight Show host Jimmy Fallon to a cuddly sloth.

ROBERT Irwin continues Steve's legacy.

What $11.9m can get you on Coast's most exclusive street

29-31 Wyuna Drive Noosaville Qld 4566

This is what a cool $11.9m can get you

How a first home buyer built house with no deposit

NEARLY THERE: Construction on the first house to home orphans at Umoja began in January.



Photo Contributed

His home will be completed later this year.

Just a lazy $2.9 million, this hideaway could be yours

Fancy a rainforest hideaway?

“We figured we wanted to spend more time outside."

ROOM FOR RENT: Airbnb market takes off in Toowoomba

Airbnb places are popping up faster than ever before in Toowoomba

Single dad, four kids, turned away from 12 homes. Why?

Sole parent Derek Fenech, with his daughters Amelio, 2, and Katherine, 1, is desperate to find a home for his family of four in Mackay.

Family of five knocked back for rentals in Mackay.

Ready to SELL your property?

Post Your Ad Here!