Entertainment

One of the biggest disasters of Scorsese’s career?

Andrew Garfield and Shin'ya Tsukamoto in a scene from the movie Silence.
Andrew Garfield and Shin'ya Tsukamoto in a scene from the movie Silence. Kerry Brown

WOULDN'T it be funny if Deadpool got an Oscar nomination for Best Picture but Martin Scorsese's 30-year labour-of-love prestige project, Silence, didn't?

It could happen.

So far Silence is unambiguously the biggest flop of Hollywood awards season.

With its heavy subject matter and historical weight, plus the irresistible detail that the completion of the film represents a triumph because it took one of Hollywood's greatest filmmakers 28 years to get it made after the director first read the novel Silence back in the 1980s, Silence had "Oscar contender" written all over it.

In the film, Andrew Garfield and Adam Driver play Portuguese Jesuit priests searching for a fellow padre (Liam Neeson) who has gone missing in 17th century Japan, where the ruling Buddhists are capturing, torturing and murdering Catholics who refuse to renounce their faith.

In early December, one early reviewer, Roger Friedman of Showbiz 411 said, in a story blasted out to the world via the Drudge Report, that Silence is "a masterwork that is set to ambush the awards race."

Adam Driver and Andrew Garfield in a scene from the movie Silence.
Adam Driver and Andrew Garfield in a scene from the movie Silence. Contributed

But as the film heads into wide release after doing so-so numbers in a limited number of theatres in the US since Christmas Day, it has no momentum whatsoever.

This week, the film got completely left off the list of BAFTA nominations. The Producer's Guild of America didn't give it one of its ten nominations for its equivalent of Best Picture. (Last year seven of the nine PGA nominees went on to Oscar nominations for Best Picture.)

Silence was also shut-out at the SAG awards and the Golden Globes. It got the cold shoulder from the American Cinema editors. It didn't get a screenplay nomination from the Writer's Guild of America. It won zilch from the New York Film Critics Circle, the Los Angeles Film Critics Circle and the National Society of Film Critics.

There are hundreds of movie awards being given out this season. But so far the one film that was set to dominate them has captured only a measly Best Adapted Screenplay honour from the National Board of Review.

Could it be that the 160-minute film just isn't working? Even Friedman broached the possibility when he said, "The word out of Los Angeles on Sunday was that Silence was boring or something."

Or something. Some of the less reverent, least fanboyish film critics have been tearing the film to shreds. Women critics especially seem not to find much to love in the film's combination of emotional vacuity and endless repetition of scenes built around whether or not a Catholic can be coerced into stepping on an image of Jesus Christ.

Liam Neeson in a scene from the movie Silence.
Liam Neeson in a scene from the movie Silence. Kerry Brown

"The torture porn is spectacularly inventive. But its commercial compromises may drive you to distraction ... it is punishingly repetitive and, at nearly three hours, sooooooo, sooooooo long," wrote Deborah Ross in the Spectator (UK).

Even less charitably, Camilla Long of London's Sunday Times wrote, "What is this film actually about? If there is an actor who can persuade me that stamping on an image of Christ is a moment of thrilling drama, it is not Garfield ... It is Scorsese at his most sentimental and his weakest. Halfway into its interminable 161 minutes, I realised that Silence stood for something else as well: the silence of fans and critics, or anyone who might say what a flimsy, tokenistic, ego-driven brainfart it is."

The New York Times' Manohla Dargis derided the film's "crushing lack of urgency" and Kate Taylor of the Globe and Mail said "Without any engaging answer to those questions, the film's emotional tension slackens."

Even the critics who liked the film, such as Peter DeBruge of Variety, admitted that it is "taxing," "punishingly long, frequently boring and woefully unengaging."

Silence, with its $US50 million budget, has little hope of turning a profit, but prestige pictures like this one aren't made to make money. And the Academy Awards could rescue it by throwing it a Best Picture or Best Director nomination on January 25.

But otherwise, Silence looks like one of the biggest disasters of Scorsese's career.

Silence is due to hit Aussie cinemas next month.

This article was originally published on The New York Post.

News Corp Australia

Topics:  adam driver andrew garfield liam neeson martin scorsese movies oscars the movie silence


Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Have your say on Lismore's signature tree

The Illawarra Flame Tree has been proposed as Lismore's own signature tree.

One person proposed the Illawarra flame tree, we suggest the cedar

Lunch lauds women

Organisers of the Lismore Women's Festival Luncheon Back - left to right: Zoe Dodd, Louise Collins, Sandra Handley Front - left to right: Emily Fajerman, Amelia Bolt, Lois Kelly, Zell Bennett

Festival attracts big names for its luncheon

Hollywood star to shine at high tea

STAR: Virginia Elizabeth 'Geena' Davis is an American actress, film producer, writer, former fashion model, and former archer.

Star of Beetlejuice, Thelma and Louise discussing Women and Media

Local Partners

EAT THE STREET: Save the date for this year's festival

MORE food stalls and cooking demonstrations at the signature Lismore event.

Andy Saunders brings race, family and life into comedy

ON STAGE: Australian comedian Andy Saunders wants to help us all lighten up.

Part of NORPA's Lismore Laughs 2017

BIG RIDE: Matt to bring out smiles for Smiddy

LONG WAY ROUND: Matt Muir raises his bike in triumph on his ride last year.

Fundraiser at Yamba Shores Tavern ahead of 800km charity ride

TLK trio ready to tell stories

Hip Hop outfit Teddy Lewis King are Teddy Rhodes, Mitch King and DJ Mud.

Hip hop troupe prepares to release new single

Tensions high at pointy end of MKR's round two

WHEN an ex-vegan pacifist says "I think people that score strategically need a kick in the shins”, the MKR gloves are off.

Jungle Jay sent packing from I'm a Celebrity

I'm A Celebrity ... Get Me Out Here! contestant Jay Laga'aia with Keira.

BIG friendly giant Jay Laga'aia has been eliminated from I'm A Celeb

Carson Kressley brings 'camp' to I'm a Celebrity jungle

"I am not all Park Avenue and daffodils” ... Carson Kressley.

Meet the "campest” campmate to star on I'm a Celebrity.

Star Wars: The Last Jedi mystery already solved

FILE- This undated file photo provided by Disney shows Daisey Ridley as Rey, left, and John Boyega as Finn, in a scene from the film, \"Star Wars: The Force Awakens.\" Hasbro said it is changing its Star Wars Monopoly set after an 8-year-old girl became upset that Rey, the movie's female heroine, was not included as a figure along with Darth Vader and Kylo Ren. (Disney/Lucasfilm via AP, File) MANDATORY CREDIT

A key mystery surrounding the title of episode eight has been solved

Kids' game "full of f**king paedophiles" according to dad

A mortified dad has expressed serious concerns over an online game

Lisa Marie Presley's ex caught with child pics: court

Lisa Marie Presley, at right, and her husband, Michael Lockwood back in 2010. FILE

Lisa Marie, 49, claimed she was left “sick to her stomach”

Robert Irwin introduces Jimmy Fallon to wild guests

Robert Irwin introduces Tonight Show host Jimmy Fallon to a cuddly sloth.

ROBERT Irwin continues Steve's legacy.

What $11.9m can get you on Coast's most exclusive street

29-31 Wyuna Drive Noosaville Qld 4566

This is what a cool $11.9m can get you

How a first home buyer built house with no deposit

NEARLY THERE: Construction on the first house to home orphans at Umoja began in January.



Photo Contributed

His home will be completed later this year.

Just a lazy $2.9 million, this hideaway could be yours

Fancy a rainforest hideaway?

“We figured we wanted to spend more time outside."

ROOM FOR RENT: Airbnb market takes off in Toowoomba

Airbnb places are popping up faster than ever before in Toowoomba

Single dad, four kids, turned away from 12 homes. Why?

Sole parent Derek Fenech, with his daughters Amelio, 2, and Katherine, 1, is desperate to find a home for his family of four in Mackay.

Family of five knocked back for rentals in Mackay.

Ready to SELL your property?

Post Your Ad Here!