Google search kills Shark Tank pitch

Google search kills Shark Tank pitch

A BUBBLY eco-entrepreneur could only watch on helplessly as her claims were debunked in real-time by a simple Google search during cringe-worthy scenes on Tuesday night's Shark Tank.

Melbourne mother and daughter team Irina Zikner, 56, and Lilly Stesin, 36, entered the episode seeking a $110,000 investment for 30 per cent of their company I Love Earth, which sells a range of collapsible, reusable silicone coffee cups and containers.

The cups, billed as a "twist on conventional reusable coffee cups", are currently stocked in more than 60 cafes in Melbourne and Byron Bay and the company has already made $15,000 profit off sales of $32,000.

"We became really, really concerned about the situation of waste pollution in Australia, where one billion coffee cups annually and growing end up in landfill," Lilly said.

"We realised that the reusable cups that are out in the market today had several fundamental problems - they were leaky, they were bulky, if they were made of glass they could break, and if they were made of plastic they could leach harmful chemicals into the hot drinks."

‘We’re a movement.’
‘We’re a movement.’

Enthusing about how they were going to change the world and cut down on waste, Lilly said they were "more than just a brand".

"We're a movement," Irina added.

While the Sharks - with the exception of eye-rolling tech entrepreneur Steve Baxter - loved the pair's energy, they struggled to get straight answers to their questions and quickly found nothing about the business added up.

I Love Earth claimed to have just one other competitor.
I Love Earth claimed to have just one other competitor.

"What does one of these cost to make?" asked investor Andrew Banks.

"Okay, so at the moment, because we don't have economies of scale, at the moment it costs us to make, and don't get frightened because it is a little bit expensive …"

"Just tell us the number," Andrew cut in.

"It's $5.20, yeah but wait, that's including shipping, that's including taxes, that's including duties, that's including all of our marketing ..."

Steve Baxter found that hard to believe.
Steve Baxter found that hard to believe.

Greencross founder Glen Richards jumped in. "Can you get rid of all the fluff and just go straight to the real cost of making that, landed?" he said.

"I can get it down to, if I order 100,000 units from our factory, $2.20," Lilly said.

Sure enough, a Google search shows ‘they’re everywhere’.
Sure enough, a Google search shows ‘they’re everywhere’.

Glen was concerned that the lid and heat sleeve were made of plastic, so the product wasn't as environmentally friendly as they claimed. He added he was "a little worried" to learn, upon further questioning, that the silicone portion would only last for 18 months.

Then it was Steve's turn to get stuck in.

Naomi Simson isn’t impressed with Steve’s antics.
Naomi Simson isn’t impressed with Steve’s antics.

"Are you the only people to do collapsible coffee mugs?" he asked.

"Yes, in Australia we're the only ones that are doing collapsible coffee cups," Lilly said.

Steve wasn't having it. "That makes no sense," he hit back.

Janine Allis likes their enthusiasm.
Janine Allis likes their enthusiasm.

Lilly tried to explain. "No, no, no, so in America there is one other company that does collapsible silicone coffee cups, there's just one other competitor," she said.

"Just one other? So if I were to Google it I wouldn't find like about the first page full of competitors?" he asked.

"No, not a brand," Lilly said.

So Steve whipped out his phone to have a look.

"They're everywhere," he said, reeling off Google search results.

"'Shop for collapsible coffee cup … Silicone coffee cup collapsible … Portable collapsible.'

Andrew Banks reckons their costs are too high.
Andrew Banks reckons their costs are too high.

"When you're talking to investors, don't have them Google it, find the competitor, and then wonder what else you've told us that's not correct. That's the problem you've now got.

"Now honestly, I don't like the feel of it, [and] I don't like being preached to when it comes to my choices in consumer goods."

Glen Richards says their cup isn’t actually that environmentally friendly.
Glen Richards says their cup isn’t actually that environmentally friendly.

Steve pulled out, followed by Andrew, who said felt the cost of making the product was too high. Glen said he thought their movement was "really important", but they needed to do a lot more work around the materials and design.

RedBalloon founder Naomi Simson said she loved their passion but felt the business wasn't unique enough, while Boost Juice founder Janine Allis said she wouldn't invest but might be willing to stock some of their products once they fixed the design.

They pair said they weren't fazed because "we know we're going to make it".

"We have the belief," Lilly said.

Shark Tank returns to Channel 10 on Tuesday, July 24, at 8.30pm.


The show must go on, and we will love it

The show must go on, and we will love it

Community wants to come together rain, hail or shine

Tailor and cut above the rest

Tailor and cut above the rest

Lismore's Bespoke Tailor

Don't forget gumboots

Don't forget gumboots

Lismore Show set to go for the weekend

Local Partners