A still from a Facebook video showing police attempting to arrest a woman near the Wreck at Byron Bay.
A still from a Facebook video showing police attempting to arrest a woman near the Wreck at Byron Bay. Contributed Jaicey Revelle Faceb

Police did not cross the line: YOU SAID

Update 3.46pm: ON MONDAY afternoon, an altercation ensued as police attempted to arrest a young woman at Byron Bay.

With the rise of social media, police are increasingly scrutinised for their actions on social media.

But our readers have responded differently.

An overwhelming 80 per cent of respondents said they did not think police crossed the line.

One reader from Currumbin said: "They should be applauded".


Original story 5am: A RETIRED North Coast police officer has spoken out about tactics used by officers in a controversial beach arrest at Byron Bay.

Charles Halloran said the shaky footage made it difficult to assess what force was being used by officers on an 18-year-old woman at Main Beach on Monday afternoon.


But based on the mobile phone video police acted above board, the ex-Byron Bay cop said.

"I think they were doing what was required of them," Mr Halloran said.

"It's hard to comprehend unless you're in the situation.

"I think someone needs to be the enforcer. The police I think are the ones to do it."

Mr Halloran, who worked in Byron Bay before he retired in 2000, recognised times had changes since he was in the force.

He was concerned about video snippets of police incidents being spread on social media without the full context.

He called on the State Government to bring forward its roll-out of body worn cameras to Byron Bay scheduled for May.

After the latest violent arrest it was vital Byron police could "tell their side of the story", he said.

The Police Association of NSW would not comment on specifics of the incident because the matter is before the court.

Tweed/Byron Local Area Command branch official Darren McCaughey said "police aren't punching bags or there to be abused".

"Our police members want to keep the community safe, but in doing so want to keep themselves safe and go home to their families," Mr McCaughey said.

Speaking broadly about police conduct, the command's crime manager Brendan Cullen said his officers were "very professional" in the "difficult job" they did.

"They are trained and taught with how to deal with members of the public," Detective Chief Inspector Cullen said.

"They want to keep people safe and that's their goal."

Do you think police crossed the line during arrest?

This poll ended on 14 February 2018.

Current Results





This is not a scientific poll. The results reflect only the opinions of those who chose to participate.

The Kiss

The Kiss

Lionel's favourite photo

Travelling on a plane full of Michelin men

Travelling on a plane full of Michelin men

Airdre on the consequences of having more than 7 kilos of carry on

Education in the gallery is vital

Education in the gallery is vital

Our educational offering has grown exponentially

Local Partners