Opinion

Pollies blinded to the science

TWO SCU scientists made national news headlines this week with their study into the fugitive emissions of gas fields in Queensland. Dr Isaac Santos and Dr Damien Maher have done the first studies into background levels of methane in the atmosphere (typically found at around 1.8 parts per million in areas where there is no gas exploration) and comparing that to the levels of methane around the Tara gas fields, where they found readings as high as 7 parts per million in some locations.

Their findings, whilst preliminary, could have a number of implications for coal seam gas producers.

The main justification for developing the industry is that gas is a 'transition fuel' that has significantly lower emissions than burning coal. But if the levels of 'fugitive emissions' detected by the SCU scientists are found consistently around gas producing areas, the whole raison d'etre disappears in an explosive methane fuelled fireball, because apparently methane that escapes into the atmosphere (as opposed to being burnt) is a much more serious greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide.

The other thing that could be a game-changer for the industry is that if the fugitive emissions can be quantified and attract a carbon tax, then the economic model falls apart.

Predictably, the industry has come out and criticised the research as being 'premature' and lacking scientific rigour.

But then on Tuesday the Federal Minister for Resources Martin Ferguson spoke out at an energy conference in Sydney, describing the scientists involved as "people who are trying to score political points without proper consideration of the best interests of the broader community" (Sydney Morning Herald, November 20).

He also admitted that he had not read the study by Dr Santos and Dr Maher.

This is an incredible attack on the credibility and independence of the scientists and, to me, the clearest indication yet that both federal and state governments are so cosy with sections of the mining industry that they are prepared to do their bidding for them.

Sure there needs to be a lot more research done, but to dismiss it out of hand smacks of outrageous complicity.

Topics:  opinion


Join the Community.

Get your local news, your way.

Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

A bishop of balance built his flock

SADDENED: Service for Bishop Satterthwaite at Lismore Cathedral

Bishop Satterthwaite was given a warm farewell this week.

South Lismore Primary’s Miss World hopeful says ‘she can’

SHE CAN: Miss World finalist Janaya Everingham outside her old primary school.

Lismore's Miss World Finalist makes it happen for Variety charity

BUDGET 2016: Tax cuts for firms pulling in up to $10m

Australian Federal Treasurer Scott Morrison speaks at the despatch box during the delivery of the 2016-17 Federal Budget in the House of Representatives at Parliament House in Canberra,

It will cost the federal government $5.3 billion in lost revenue

Latest deals and offers

Lismore Eisteddfod is in need of funds to secure its future

Supporters of Lismore's Esiteddfod need to find funds to keep show running at City Hall

A bishop of balance built his flock

SADDENED: Service for Bishop Satterthwaite at Lismore Cathedral

Bishop Satterthwaite was given a warm farewell this week.

South Lismore Primary’s Miss World hopeful says ‘she can’

SHE CAN: Miss World finalist Janaya Everingham outside her old primary school.

Lismore's Miss World Finalist makes it happen for Variety charity

BUDGET 2016: Tax cuts for firms pulling in up to $10m

Australian Federal Treasurer Scott Morrison speaks at the despatch box during the delivery of the 2016-17 Federal Budget in the House of Representatives at Parliament House in Canberra,

It will cost the federal government $5.3 billion in lost revenue

Lismore has diversity Byron had

(From left) Christopher Woodward, Shanon Robb, Lora-Jean Damen and Sabrina Major model the clothes for the new fashion event Threads which will take place at the Back Alley Gallery. Photo Marc Stapelberg / The Northern Star

Lismore has what Byron had - vibrancy and diversity.

Maudeville is back, brighter and shinier than ever

DIVA: Maude Boat as MC of the Cabaret Show at a previous Tropical Fruit’s New Year Eve Party in Lismore.

IN A city full of divas, only one reigns supreme: Maude Boate.

Enjoy a barefoot belly-dance as well as a sketch

Stacey Walker and Sasha Fox from the Barefoot Gypsies look forward to Gypsy Nights to be held at their studio in Carrington Street on Saturday night. Photo Cathy Adams / The Northern Star

Let The Barefoot Gypsies entertain you

Spectacular Crash as Corvette Flips at Drag Races

Corvette flips at 350kmh.

Driver walks away from 350kmh crash in Texas.

Star Wars: Force Awakens told in Emojis

Disney has released an emoji version of The Force Awakens.

To commemorate Star Wars Day, Disney releases emoji version of film on a smart...

NYPD join dance challenge

New York Police respond to NZ dance challenge.

New York's finest accept Kiwi dance challenge.

How a sacked real estate agent made $725k in four months

Agent is now under investigation by the industry watchdog

VIDEO: Art Deco fan pays $835,000 for Imperial Hotel

No Caption

Iconic "Impy" sold at a bargan price to bidder who loves Art Deco.

RBA warns of future apartment oversupply

Toowoomba: Crest Apartments and Burke & Wills, Ruthven Street ( view from Neil Street) Photo Bev Lacey / The Chronicle

RBA says oversupply of apartments poses risk to household finances