Opinion

Pollies blinded to the science

TWO SCU scientists made national news headlines this week with their study into the fugitive emissions of gas fields in Queensland. Dr Isaac Santos and Dr Damien Maher have done the first studies into background levels of methane in the atmosphere (typically found at around 1.8 parts per million in areas where there is no gas exploration) and comparing that to the levels of methane around the Tara gas fields, where they found readings as high as 7 parts per million in some locations.

Their findings, whilst preliminary, could have a number of implications for coal seam gas producers.

The main justification for developing the industry is that gas is a 'transition fuel' that has significantly lower emissions than burning coal. But if the levels of 'fugitive emissions' detected by the SCU scientists are found consistently around gas producing areas, the whole raison d'etre disappears in an explosive methane fuelled fireball, because apparently methane that escapes into the atmosphere (as opposed to being burnt) is a much more serious greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide.

The other thing that could be a game-changer for the industry is that if the fugitive emissions can be quantified and attract a carbon tax, then the economic model falls apart.

Predictably, the industry has come out and criticised the research as being 'premature' and lacking scientific rigour.

But then on Tuesday the Federal Minister for Resources Martin Ferguson spoke out at an energy conference in Sydney, describing the scientists involved as "people who are trying to score political points without proper consideration of the best interests of the broader community" (Sydney Morning Herald, November 20).

He also admitted that he had not read the study by Dr Santos and Dr Maher.

This is an incredible attack on the credibility and independence of the scientists and, to me, the clearest indication yet that both federal and state governments are so cosy with sections of the mining industry that they are prepared to do their bidding for them.

Sure there needs to be a lot more research done, but to dismiss it out of hand smacks of outrageous complicity.

Topics:  opinion


Join the Community.

Get your local news, your way.

Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Watch Tralala Blip perform live at TEDxSydney

ON THE SPOT: Northern Rivers electronic music band Tralala Blip.

From 9am at the Sydney Opera House

Origin Blues team revealed: Five could make their debut

NSW Blues coach Laurie Daley

New South Wales coach Laurie Daley has named five debutants

Netflix internet speed test: How do you rate?

Highway 66: the speed at the Sunshine Coast Daily office.

New site allows Australians to test their mobile or broadband speed

Latest deals and offers

VIDEO: The fastest, easiest way to peel a potato?

Try not to think about how many hours you've squandered trying to clean up the humble spud.

Watch Tralala Blip perform live at TEDxSydney

ON THE SPOT: Northern Rivers electronic music band Tralala Blip.

From 9am at the Sydney Opera House

Origin Blues team revealed: Five could make their debut

NSW Blues coach Laurie Daley

New South Wales coach Laurie Daley has named five debutants

Netflix internet speed test: How do you rate?

Highway 66: the speed at the Sunshine Coast Daily office.

New site allows Australians to test their mobile or broadband speed

Golden Era musos return

Pacific Jazzmen

Lismore's legendary Jazzmen reunite.

Cultural Alliance a first for nation

NORPA Artistic Director Julian Louis and Cr Jenny Dowell at Lismore City Hall.

NORPA and Lismore City Council have signed a new Cultural Alliance.

Diesel paying tribute to artists who have influenced him

Mark Denis Lizotte, also known as Diesel.

American is a concept predominant in singer Mark Lizotte’s life

How to peel a potato fast

There is a fast way to peel potatoes.

You've been doing it wrong all this time.

Johnny Depp thinks Barnaby Joyce is inbred with a tomato.

Johnny Depp on Jimmy Kimmel Live.

Johnny Depp explains his apology video on Jimmy Kimmel Live.

IBAC Evidence Police Bashing 5

Officers drag the woman back to her cell

In this video the woman drinks water from the toilet.

Perfect time to invest in Northern Rivers property

The Northern Rivers rental market is tighter than Sydney making it the perfect time for investors to get better returns out of property than superannuation or banks deposits.

Low interest rates and tight rental market are prime time to invest