Opinion

Pollies blinded to the science

TWO SCU scientists made national news headlines this week with their study into the fugitive emissions of gas fields in Queensland. Dr Isaac Santos and Dr Damien Maher have done the first studies into background levels of methane in the atmosphere (typically found at around 1.8 parts per million in areas where there is no gas exploration) and comparing that to the levels of methane around the Tara gas fields, where they found readings as high as 7 parts per million in some locations.

Their findings, whilst preliminary, could have a number of implications for coal seam gas producers.

The main justification for developing the industry is that gas is a 'transition fuel' that has significantly lower emissions than burning coal. But if the levels of 'fugitive emissions' detected by the SCU scientists are found consistently around gas producing areas, the whole raison d'etre disappears in an explosive methane fuelled fireball, because apparently methane that escapes into the atmosphere (as opposed to being burnt) is a much more serious greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide.

The other thing that could be a game-changer for the industry is that if the fugitive emissions can be quantified and attract a carbon tax, then the economic model falls apart.

Predictably, the industry has come out and criticised the research as being 'premature' and lacking scientific rigour.

But then on Tuesday the Federal Minister for Resources Martin Ferguson spoke out at an energy conference in Sydney, describing the scientists involved as "people who are trying to score political points without proper consideration of the best interests of the broader community" (Sydney Morning Herald, November 20).

He also admitted that he had not read the study by Dr Santos and Dr Maher.

This is an incredible attack on the credibility and independence of the scientists and, to me, the clearest indication yet that both federal and state governments are so cosy with sections of the mining industry that they are prepared to do their bidding for them.

Sure there needs to be a lot more research done, but to dismiss it out of hand smacks of outrageous complicity.

Topics:  opinion


Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Feed brain and body will take care of the rest

Psychologist and author on brain nutrition and dealing with female stress, Delia McCabe, talks at Lismore's City Library.

Delia McCabe talks about her new book in Lismore: Feed The Brain.

Search for Lismore’s new supermodel

Senior finalists represented Lismore in the 2015 Tamblyn Model Discovery Grand Final.

Tamblyn Young Model Search held from Thursday at Lismore Square

Latest deals and offers

Was this band expelled from Splendour for nudity?

Melbourne bar owner says he saw UK rock band Fat White Family being escorted out of the backstage area

Search for Lismore’s new supermodel

Senior finalists represented Lismore in the 2015 Tamblyn Model Discovery Grand Final.

Tamblyn Young Model Search held from Thursday at Lismore Square

Woolworths to sack 500 staff, close at least 17 stores

This is despite the supermarket earning $2.5 billion for the year.

The best and worst bits of Splendour from our experts

The Amphitheatre received Flume with open arms and danced to his music on Sunday night.

Glitter, fake marriages, see-through clothing and gorgeous weather

Splendour found The Cure

Robert Smith at the Splendour in the Grass Amphitheatre stage during The Cure's show.

Day two of Splendour in the Grass

Gallery donations roll with thanks

Donors gather at The Regional Art Gallery hear from the architect, Dominic Finlay Jones, about the redevelopment of the gallery.

Regional Gallery thanks donors helping with redevelopment

NORPA brings My Radio Heart back

Performers in the NORPA co-production My Radio Heart, from left, Randolf Reimann, Phoebe Rose, Mathew Daymond, Claudie Frock, Zac Mifsud (sitting), and Lydian Dunbar. Photo Cathy Adams / The Northern Star

The piece premiered in 2014 in Lismore

Mariah Carey: I 'can't believe' Prince has gone

'Prince was one of the best people I've met'

Joe Jonas' 'tough' pals

Joe Jonas' pals are 'tough' with his potential partners

The Bachelor wash up: bacon, plank offs and that white rose

Richie Strahan, second from left, with bachelorettes Eliza, Faith, Noni and Janey in a scene from episode one of the fourth season of The Bachelor.

RICHIE Strahan meets some beautiful, and colourful, bachelorettes.

What's on the big screen this week

Matt Damon in a scene from the movie Jason Bourne.

MATT Damon returnx in the spy thriller Jason Bourne.

MOVIE REVIEW: Goldstone sure to become Aussie classic

Aaron Pedersen and Alex Russell in a scene from the movie Goldstone.

DIRECTOR Ivan Sen and Aaron Pedersen reunite for Mystery Road sequel

You can own this Queensland town for just $1

Yelarbon

Unprecedented auction of town's business centre with no reserve

Work starts on $15M Caloundra apartment building

Turning the first sod at the Aqua View Apartments site in Kings Beach are (from left) husband-and-wife developers Alex Yuan and Stella Sun with construction company Tomkins director Mike Tomkins and Councillor Tim Dwyer.

Developers excited about addition to Kings Beach skyline

Plans revealed for 1500-lot 'master-planned community'

Precinct will be bounded by Boundary St and Shoesmith Rd

Ecco Ripley sales run sparks prime release

MOVING IN: Sekisui House has announced the release of more residential blocks at Ecco Ripley.

Sekisui House is preparing to unveil more land at Ecco Ripley

Massive residential 9-storey high-rise hit by delays

An artist’s impression of the eight-storey-high apartment complex that Bernoth Holdings wants to build in South Toowoomba, next to the City Golf Club.

Developer struggles to get approved high-rise development started